by Why Kingpin Deserves the Joker Treatment
To understand why this idea is generating buzz, you have to first understand what Kingpin represents in the Marvel universe. Unlike cosmic threats like Thanos or mystical villains like Dormammu, Wilson Fisk is terrifying because he feels real. He’s grounded in the gritty, brutal reality of New York’s underworld — a man who rose through the ranks of corruption, pain, and trauma to become one of Marvel’s most intimidating forces.
What separates Fisk from your run-of-the-mill villain is his complexity. He’s not evil for the sake of it. There’s method to his madness. There’s heartbreak beneath his violence. And most importantly, there’s a child inside the man — one who was once vulnerable, scared, and powerless.
This is where D’Onofrio’s vision strikes gold. In a recent interview, he floated the idea of a story titled “The Story of Art Fisk” — a concept that would take the character away from the typical superhero showdowns and place him in a narrative space more akin to Joker (2019), which redefined what a comic book character study could be.
Vincent D’Onofrio said:
“I’d like to do something like, ‘What if…?’ The story of Art Fisk. I just want to explore him outside of the usual villain/superhero combination. I’d love to see a more realistic version, similar to what they did with Joker…with a more introspective approach and, you know, 10 times more than what they’ve done with Joker so far. It’s dark.”
Can you imagine Marvel diving into the psychological decay, emotional trauma, and inner monologue of Wilson Fisk before he ever wore a white suit or smashed heads into car doors? That’s the kind of storytelling Marvel has barely touched — and it’s a space that Kingpin could completely own.
Echo: A Glimpse of What’s Possible
The recent Disney+ series Echo, which introduced Marvel’s new “Spotlight” branding, offered fans a taste of a more grounded, character-driven approach. Centered on Maya Lopez (played by Alaqua Cox), the series brought back Kingpin in a big way. While it focused on Maya’s personal journey, Kingpin’s presence was undeniable — and honestly, it reignited fan interest in his character on a whole new level.
Critics, including Molly Freeman from Screen Rant, praised Echo for its “breathless fight scenes” and “stunningly unique voice.” The series stood out by being more intimate and raw than Marvel’s typical cosmic or multiversal stories. This is the direction fans have been craving — stories with emotional stakes, raw performances, and flawed, human characters.
And if there’s one thing Echo confirmed, it’s that Vincent D’Onofrio hasn’t lost a step. His performance was once again chilling, magnetic, and deeply nuanced. It reminded us just how rich the character of Fisk can be — and why now is the perfect time to explore his past.
Reimagining Art Fisk: What Could the Story Look Like?
Let’s break down what a “Joker-style” Kingpin origin movie or limited series might actually look like. First, it wouldn’t be a typical Marvel project. It would likely fall under the Marvel Spotlight umbrella, which emphasizes character-first storytelling over big CGI spectacle. Think Logan, but even darker.
Imagine this:
Setting: A gritty, 1980s Hell’s Kitchen, filled with crime, poverty, and systemic failure.
Plot: A young Wilson Fisk grows up under the shadow of an abusive father. He sees his mother suffer in silence. Bullied at school. Isolated from the world. One traumatic incident leads him to commit a violent act — and that’s the moment everything changes.
Tone: Psychological, noir-like, filled with voiceover narration, slow-burn tension, and mental unraveling.
Inspiration: Films like Taxi Driver, Requiem for a Dream, and of course, Joker — movies that aren’t afraid to explore the broken corners of the human psyche.
This wouldn’t just be a Kingpin origin story. It would be Marvel’s first full-fledged villain character study — a deep dive into how trauma, environment, and rage can shape a man into a monster.
A New Frontier for Marvel
Let’s be real: Marvel is at a turning point. After the high of Endgame, the franchise has struggled with consistency. Phase Four and parts of Phase Five have been hit-or-miss, with fans craving deeper storytelling and less reliance on multiverse gimmicks.
A Kingpin solo story offers Marvel a unique chance to pivot into more serious, mature territory. It doesn’t require a $200 million budget or a dozen cameos. What it needs is solid writing, a visionary director, and Vincent D’Onofrio doing what he does best — making us believe that Wilson Fisk is both monster and man.
Marvel can look at what Joker achieved: over $1 billion at the global box office and 11 Oscar nominations. But even more importantly, it proved there’s an audience for dark, character-driven comic book stories. Fans want more than flashy battles. They want meaning. Emotion. Tragedy.
Let’s break down what a “Joker-style” Kingpin origin movie or limited series might actually look like. First, it wouldn’t be a typical Marvel project. It would likely fall under the Marvel Spotlight umbrella, which emphasizes character-first storytelling over big CGI spectacle. Think Logan, but even darker.
Imagine this:
- Setting: A gritty, 1980s Hell’s Kitchen, filled with crime, poverty, and systemic failure.
- Plot: A young Wilson Fisk grows up under the shadow of an abusive father. He sees his mother suffer in silence. Bullied at school. Isolated from the world. One traumatic incident leads him to commit a violent act — and that’s the moment everything changes.
- Tone: Psychological, noir-like, filled with voiceover narration, slow-burn tension, and mental unraveling.
- Inspiration: Films like Taxi Driver, Requiem for a Dream, and of course, Joker — movies that aren’t afraid to explore the broken corners of the human psyche.
This wouldn’t just be a Kingpin origin story. It would be Marvel’s first full-fledged villain character study — a deep dive into how trauma, environment, and rage can shape a man into a monster.
D’Onofrio: The Heart of Fisk
Vincent D’Onofrio is not just an actor playing a role — he is Kingpin. Since his first appearance in Netflix’s Daredevil back in 2015, he’s brought an operatic weight to the character. His version of Fisk isn’t just a thug — he’s cultured, emotional, and terrifyingly intelligent.
What makes D’Onofrio’s portrayal so powerful is the way he balances brutality with vulnerability. One moment, he’s smashing someone’s head into a wall. The next, he’s whispering sweet words to Vanessa like a wounded romantic. That duality is what makes Kingpin unforgettable — and what could make an origin story genuinely heartbreaking.
As we await Daredevil: Born Again (currently undergoing creative changes at Marvel), it’s the perfect time to give D’Onofrio room to expand the character beyond hero-versus-villain dynamics. Let Fisk take the spotlight — fully, unapologetically, and emotionally.
Final Thoughts: Let the King Reign
As a 25-year-old boy who grew up idolizing Marvel heroes but slowly found myself more fascinated by its villains, I think a Joker-style origin for Kingpin is not just a good idea — it’s a necessary evolution for Marvel storytelling.
It would challenge the studio to step outside its comfort zone. It would give fans something fresh and meaningful. And it would allow Vincent D’Onofrio to cement his legacy as one of the greatest performers the MCU has ever seen.
In a world overflowing with superheroes, maybe it’s time we spent a little more time with the broken men behind the mask. And if that journey starts with Wilson Fisk — then sign me up.
If you’re interested in reading more blogs like this, click here.
