by As someone who’s spent the last five years blogging about movies—from superhero blockbusters to emotional biopics—I’ve learned that the real magic often lies in stories grounded in truth. And that’s exactly what Nyad delivers: a deeply personal, emotionally charged, and occasionally polarizing true story brought to life by two acting powerhouses.
Based on the incredible real-life story of Diana Nyad, a marathon swimmer who at age 64 became the first person to swim from Cuba to Florida without a shark cage, Nyad is more than just a sports drama. It’s a meditation on obsession, aging, friendship, and the limits of human endurance. Directed by Oscar-winning documentary filmmakers Jimmy Chin and Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi (best known for Free Solo), Nyad manages to walk the line between cinematic dramatization and documentary realism. And while it isn’t a perfect film, it’s a worthy and inspiring entry in the sports biopic genre.
Annette Bening: A Force of Nature
Annette Bening, who portrays Diana Nyad, is the engine that powers this film. She fully transforms into the stubborn, often unlikeable but fiercely passionate swimmer. Her performance is raw, intense, and surprisingly physical. There’s no sugarcoating here—Diana isn’t portrayed as a saint. She’s obsessive, arrogant, and sometimes dismissive of the people who support her. But Bening makes her compelling to watch, capturing both the mental and physical toll of such an undertaking.
What makes her performance even more remarkable is the physicality she brings to the role. You can feel the pain, the fatigue, and the toll of the ocean on her aging body. And credit must go to the makeup and costume departments for not glamorizing the ordeal. Bening often looks rough, weathered, and exhausted—which is exactly how she should look during a 100+ mile swim.
Jodie Foster: The Heart of the Film
Jodie Foster plays Bonnie Stoll, Nyad’s best friend, coach, and emotional anchor. While her role may seem secondary, it’s essential. Foster brings warmth and humanity to the story, offering a counterbalance to Nyad’s often prickly personality. Their dynamic is one of the film’s strongest elements—their friendship is genuine, complex, and grounded in years of shared struggle.
It’s not your typical mentor-athlete relationship. Bonnie often questions Nyad’s decisions and motivations, but never abandons her. In many ways, she’s the emotional barometer of the film, offering a perspective the audience can relate to. Foster and Bening have excellent chemistry, and their scenes together provide some of the film’s most touching and authentic moments.
The Real Challenge: Making Swimming Cinematic
One of the major hurdles Nyad faces—and largely overcomes—is making the act of long-distance swimming visually compelling. Let’s be honest: watching someone swim in open water for hours isn’t inherently exciting. But the directors use a variety of cinematic techniques—underwater shots, time-lapses, close-ups of Nyad’s face, and montage sequences—to maintain tension and momentum.
Still, the film’s pacing does lag at times. The middle act, in particular, feels repetitive. There are multiple failed attempts at the swim, each with its own set of challenges—jellyfish stings, storms, hallucinations, and exhaustion. While these scenes are important to show the immense difficulty of the task, they could have been trimmed to keep the narrative tighter.
A Controversial Legacy
One of the most interesting aspects of Nyad is what it leaves out or only hints at: the controversy surrounding her swim. Some open-water swimming experts and athletes have questioned the validity of Nyad’s achievement, citing lack of complete GPS data and unverified methods. The film touches on this lightly but never dives deep.
This is a missed opportunity. Addressing the controversy more directly could have added a fascinating layer to the story—showing how Nyad dealt with criticism, doubt, and the pressure to defend her legacy. That said, it’s understandable that the filmmakers chose to focus on the emotional and physical journey rather than turning the movie into an investigative exposé.
Themes of Aging and Perseverance
What sets Nyad apart from other sports films is its focus on aging. Nyad wasn’t a young phenom with her whole career ahead of her. She was a 64-year-old woman fighting against not just the ocean, but the assumptions society places on older people—especially women. The film powerfully portrays how age can be both a limitation and a source of strength.
Nyad’s obsession with finishing the swim becomes a metaphor for unfinished business in life. She never got the Olympic medals or the recognition she craved in her youth, and this swim becomes her last shot at glory. It’s a compelling narrative hook, and one that many viewers—especially those facing their own midlife crossroads—will find relatable.
Technical Brilliance
The cinematography by Claudio Miranda (known for Life of Pi) deserves special mention. The ocean is both a character and a setting in Nyad—vast, threatening, beautiful, and mysterious. Miranda captures all these elements with grace. The score, too, complements the visual storytelling without overwhelming it.
The editing is tight for the most part, and the sound design during the swimming scenes immerses you in the action. You can hear the water, the breathing, the ambient noises of the sea—all of which add to the sense of realism.
Final Verdict: Is Nyad Worth Watching?
Absolutely. Nyad isn’t just a film about swimming—it’s about grit, ambition, friendship, and legacy. Annette Bening delivers a performance that deserves serious awards attention, and Jodie Foster is the perfect counterbalance. While the film isn’t without its flaws—pacing issues, some emotional beats that don’t fully land, and a missed opportunity to explore controversy—it’s still a compelling, human story.
If you’re a fan of sports dramas that go beyond the surface, or you simply want to see two veteran actresses at the top of their game, Nyad is worth your time. And for bloggers like me who thrive on finding emotional depth in unexpected places, this movie is a treasure.
If you’re interested in reading more blogs like this, click here
